user name

password   (forgot)

   Register





erdos0
Profile
Blog
Comments
  blog rss


            
The Virtually Indestructible Mouse Destroyed
Mon May 10, 2010 10:50:11 pm


re:
Review: The Virtually Indestructible Mouse
Thu Jun 18, 2009 6:27:33 am

virtually indestructible mouse box frontvirtually indestructible mouse box back
virtually indestructible mouse

I have had this mouse for about a week now. I chose it because it is waterproof and can survive repeated falls from my desk. The case is made from a single piece of silicone which seals out water from the internal electronics. The casing also allows the mouse to bounce nicely off the floor instead of cracking.

The softness and texture of the case makes the mouse very comfortable to hold, but it also creates a serious drawback. I noticed from my first use of it that the buttons require more force to press than on an ordinary mouse. This is a consequence of using a single piece of silicone for the case which covers both the buttons and the body of the mouse. The silicone has to flex to accommodate the motion of a mouse button press. It's not an extreme amount of force, but it's noticeable.

For casual use, this is fine, but I use the computer for many hours every day. I can feel the repetitive stress injury developing. I had to change my finger alignment to avoid injury. It's not really an issue of finger muscle strength. The problem is that I typically press down with my finger parallel to the mouse button. This creates shearing forces on the joint which are negligible on an ordinary mouse, but it's noticeable on this one. I have to adjust to a more perpendicular finger contact position when pressing to avoid injury, but it's less comfortable. I thought the resistance of the mouse would soften a bit after some use, but it seems to have only softened very little after a week.
I think it might be my longest lasting mouse ever, but it died today. I had been experiencing brief periods of unresponsiveness from the mouse over the past few days but couldn't find any obvious physical problems with it. Total failure happened today. The cable broke at the point where it meets the mouse body. One of the three lines is completely severed. The other two are still working and was able to cause the red light to flicker, but the computer was giving errors about not being able to identify the device. Upon closer inspection, I finally saw the break which still was not visible yesterday.

I am currently using an old mouse that skips a lot, which is very annoying. It's time to do research to find an even more indestructible mouse, or one just so weird that I have to have it.
 prevnextfirstlast   12
1) erdos0,
Mon May 10, 2010 10:55:30 pm


Interesting
2) erdos0,
Mon May 10, 2010 10:58:52 pm

3) erdos0,
Mon May 10, 2010 11:20:17 pm

re: comment#2
I decided to get this because it's only $2.80. The original price was $19.99 but it was marked down. I'm sure it's because people realized how stupid it is to use in the intended way. You would have to hold your hand still until you want to move the pointer. I intend to attach it to a pen or something else to turn it into a unique but usable pointing device.

I also ordered this:

This one is for daily use. The other one is for experimentation.
4) evilserif,
Tue May 11, 2010 6:50:43 am

re: comment#3
I decided to get this because it's only $2.80. The original price was $19.99 but it was marked down. I'm sure it's because people realized how stupid it is to use in the intended way. You would have to hold your hand still until you want to move the pointer. I intend to attach it to a pen or something else to turn it into a unique but usable pointing device.

I also ordered this:

This one is for daily use. The other one is for experimentation.
sweet.
5) monkeysoup,
Tue May 11, 2010 6:57:28 am

I don't think the manufacturer intended for you to play Tetherball with the VIRTUALLY INDESTRUCTIBLE MOUSe.
6) monkeysoup,
Tue May 11, 2010 6:57:53 am

re: comment#1

Interesting
I would modify this mouse by extending the handle downward, to be gripped inside the palm, with the buttons and maybe a scroll wheel placed where they can be operated by the middle and ring fingers. As it is, I don't see how one could easily click and drag.
7) monkeysoup,
Tue May 11, 2010 6:58:11 am

re: comment#3
I decided to get this because it's only $2.80. The original price was $19.99 but it was marked down. I'm sure it's because people realized how stupid it is to use in the intended way. You would have to hold your hand still until you want to move the pointer. I intend to attach it to a pen or something else to turn it into a unique but usable pointing device.

I also ordered this:

This one is for daily use. The other one is for experimentation.
Interesting.
8) monkeysoup,
Tue May 11, 2010 7:00:40 am

re: comment#6
I would modify this mouse by extending the handle downward, to be gripped inside the palm, with the buttons and maybe a scroll wheel placed where they can be operated by the middle and ring fingers. As it is, I don't see how one could easily click and drag.
I suppose Lefties could manage, but it would still be awkward.
9) erdos0,
Tue May 11, 2010 2:35:11 pm

re: comment#5
I don't think the manufacturer intended for you to play Tetherball with the VIRTUALLY INDESTRUCTIBLE MOUSe.
They should say that in the manual.
10) erdos0,
Tue May 11, 2010 2:36:39 pm

re: comment#6
I would modify this mouse by extending the handle downward, to be gripped inside the palm, with the buttons and maybe a scroll wheel placed where they can be operated by the middle and ring fingers. As it is, I don't see how one could easily click and drag.
I think this would give me repetitive stress injury in my thumb even if the dragging problem is fixed.
11) erdos0,
Tue May 11, 2010 2:38:19 pm

re: comment#4
sweet.
It's a vertical mouse. The hand position is supposedly better for the wrist. I haven't tried it and don't know how much better it is. I bought it only because it's very different.
12) erdos0,
Tue May 11, 2010 2:40:40 pm

re: comment#8
I suppose Lefties could manage, but it would still be awkward.
A right handed person could wear it on the left hand. It's still awkward either way. Typing has to be done with one hand and the mouse hand has to stay still all the time, unless the user is not distracted by a pointer that randomly dances around the screen.
13) evilserif,
Tue May 11, 2010 3:44:22 pm

re: comment#11
It's a vertical mouse. The hand position is supposedly better for the wrist. I haven't tried it and don't know how much better it is. I bought it only because it's very different.
Huh. Well, keep up updated.
14) erdos0,
Tue May 11, 2010 4:06:29 pm

re: comment#13
Huh. Well, keep up updated.
I will.
15) monkeysoup,
Wed May 12, 2010 9:56:35 am

agrees with: comment#9
They should say that in the manual.
16) monkeysoup,
Wed May 12, 2010 9:57:55 am

re: comment#10
I think this would give me repetitive stress injury in my thumb even if the dragging problem is fixed.
Yes, it does not look like a comfortable position or range of motion for the thumb.
17) monkeysoup,
Wed May 12, 2010 9:59:45 am

re: comment#12
A right handed person could wear it on the left hand. It's still awkward either way. Typing has to be done with one hand and the mouse hand has to stay still all the time, unless the user is not distracted by a pointer that randomly dances around the screen.
Oh, I meant the one with the trackball. Using it with the left hand you could press the left button with the forefinger. I did not consider that by configuring the functions of the buttons this could be done with the right hand. An additional button with a click-lock function would be much better.
18) erdos0,
Wed May 12, 2010 3:47:47 pm

re: comment#17
Oh, I meant the one with the trackball. Using it with the left hand you could press the left button with the forefinger. I did not consider that by configuring the functions of the buttons this could be done with the right hand. An additional button with a click-lock function would be much better.
The thumb might be able to activate the buttons when it's mounted on the right hand, but it would be a very uncomfortable and possibly damaging position. When mounted on the left hand, the right hand would have to be used to activate the buttons. It's still possible, but it's very inconvenient.
19) erdos0,
Wed May 26, 2010 8:30:08 pm

re: comment#13
Huh. Well, keep up updated.
The one finger mouse is very inconvenient to use. The main problem is in operating the buttons. It is impossible to use them when wearing it on the finger, because my thumb cannot cross over that far. This makes it a two handed mouse. I discovered a way to operate it with one hand, but it requires a very awkward position that is totally different from the illustration. Because it's very light weight and the button is on the side, keeping the mouse stable while pressing the buttons requires tightly grasping the mouse.

The vertical mouse is very good. It's definitely more ergonomic than a regular one, but I still need a little wrist support to get the ideal position.
20) rubberchicken,
Fri Sep 9, 2011 10:32:58 pm

re: comment#2
I bought this one yesterday as a backup from MeritLine with with coupon code MLC9E8GN for $7:

Logitech V150 Laser Notebook Mouse, New with White Box



Nothing special, just a regular cheap mouse.
 prevnextfirstlast   12